Hi! It's me, Mintleaf. I just want to talk about Mapleshade. I think Mapleshade was going to be a great warrior, but after ThunderClan and RiverClan rejected her, she went bad. I feel sorry for her; Mapleshade loved her mate, and she had kits. But after she told ThunderClan her secret, they rejected her from the clan, along with her kits! Mapleshade tried to carry them to RiverClan, but she lost balance and they drowned. Mapleshade's mate blamed her, and RiverClan casted her out! It's just sad that Mapleshade was cast out to live as a loner. I would get revenge, too. Look at Leafpool and Crowfeather! They need to be punished, badly. I think Leafpool and Crowfeather should have been banished, instead of Mapleshade. Leafpool was a medicine cat! Mapleshade wasn't the only cat who loved a different clan cat. Why should she alone be banished from the clan? Bluestar loved Oakheart, Leafpool loved Crowfeather, Crowfeather also loved Feathertail, and Ryewhisker loved Cloudberry! It's just not fair! It was Mapleshade who had the worst punishment, when there were much much worse cats! I think Leafpool should have been banished. What do you think?